Hello, I hope you remember my, I’m the fake poster. I did a full confession on Reddit, I compiled over 40 of my fake stories. I had chosen AmITheAngel because it is the most adequate place to talk about fake stories on Reddit.

I’ll also post the full text in here so you don’t have to go to reddit. Here it is.

AITA for making over 40+ fake posts on reddit?

This is my confession, and at the end of this post, you will find a list of 40+ fake post I wrote on Reddit. But first, let me introduce myself, so you might have a little insight on what was happening on my mind.

My name is Valentine. For almost a year I posted over 40 fake posts on Reddit. There are a lot more, but these are the ones I’ve been able to find and recover.

Let me tell you about me. I’m 24 years old, I was introduced to Reddit by my nephew, and for the following years, I’ve been hooked to the platform.

I started listening to many Reddit story time podcasts. Started with the Pewdiepie reaction videos, then people reading answers from AskReddit, and then Relationships and AITA. It was always entertaining, and sometimes educational. I even got my boyfriend hooked into them.

Sometimes I asked Reddit for advice on things that happened IRL to me, but they always died in new with one or 2 comments. Then I had an Idea. I created another Reddit account, and posted a Fake Story. The engagement was immediate and most people believed the story, until mods deleted it.

But then something had grown inside me. Some days later I made another story, from another throwaway account. A little time later, another one.

Before I knew it, it became a habit. Something would pop inside my head, then I would create another account and write it down to post it on Reddit. I became more methodical, I used character counters, LanguageTool, Deepl Write to fix my grammar, I would research a topic to make it more believable. I created these characters, and started roleplaying as them, while I wrote it and interacted with commenters, I became my own characters for a short period of time. I would let ideas for stories rest on draft to make them better and fix mistakes.

It turned into a unhealthy habit, constantly my stories would get deleted by mods, someone would catch a little mistake to call out the fake, it would turn time-consuming, stress inducing, anxiety triggering. I didn’t care about receiving hate on a character that was written to be a jerk, but the effort started to take a toll on my mental health.

This was never about Karma, awards, or followers. I gained nothing from this. I need to talk to a psychologist to try and understand my real motives since I don’t really understand it myself, but I guess the engagement was addicting, my ultimate goal was to have my story read on my favorite reddit podcasts, and I did it a few times. A few times I said “just one more, this can be a hit” but you know how that ends, it’s never just “one more”.

My writing skills improved, a lot, you might not notice from this post alone because I’m not really taking care of my grammar alone, but I’m from Venezuela, english is my second language, and it really helped me to improve my english. I have so many ideas for books and stories to write, but I always freeze, still have many doubts about my storytelling, such as: Are my characters bland and boring? Are my descriptions good enough? Am I describing too much or too little? Is my story engaging? Do I know enough about this topic to write a story about it? Is my language too formal or too casual?

On Reddit none of that matters, I can write a complete story in minutes and people will find it engaging. I can make mistakes on my writing and grammar and nobody will care. Writing the stories I actually wanna write as full books is intimidating, and I feel bad for not trusting my skills enough to start actually writing.

But of course, now I feel as a psychopath, some people after reading my stories feel upset, emotionally distressed, I might have triggered some previous real trauma on someone, I’m playing with these strangers emotions for no real reason. And yes, I sleep well at night, I’m a heavy sleeper actually. I feel bad, and guilty.

I was hesitating making my list of fake posts public because the people that engaged on them might feel betrayed, played, and used. I spoke to many of them as if OP was a real person, some has told me their personal real stories, they trusted me. This is the most psychotic thing I’ve done, and is hunting me now. But maybe some people might feel better knowing these are fake since the OPs don’t exist, and none of these fake people are actually going through an abusive or dangerous situation. I don’t really know, the ideal situation is that the posts had never been written and posted in the first place, but is too late for that.

I tried to stop but I relapsed. I need coping mechanisms to stop me from the urge to create yet another reddit account and write another distressing story. Contrary to how Reddit makes it look, getting help for mental health is not easy, and BTW, not all mental health professionals are Therapists, psychologists exists too.

I might end up leaving Reddit entirely, the API fiasco certainly helped with that, I’ve used reddit a lot less since then, and I’ve been on Lemmy ever since.

BTW, I never posted a fake story on this, my main account, I posted here about my relationship and my crazy Mother in Law, that is 100% true, I’m not stupid enough to make fakes posts on my main. I’m not a liar IRL. I’m actually very honest, brutally honest actually, and yes, that many times makes me an asshole.

This is my confession, feel free to ask questions. I wanna turn some of these stories into actual books, maybe you can help me to choose which ones. I really wish other fake posters come out, that might be another stone thrown at Reddit’s castle of glass.

And finally, I’m sorry. And please don’t think anything on Reddit is fake, real life is sometimes crazier than fiction, I have real family stories that sound crazier than the fakest fake posts, and that’s why I never tell them.

The Fake Post List:

  1. AITA for Greeting my Biodad in Public
  2. AITA for cutting finantial support for my family
  3. AITA for reporting my boss over a nickname
  4. AITA for dropping my uncle’s AP’s name at dinner after he tried to slutshame me?
  5. AITA I sold the ps4 my brother gave to my son
  6. [AITA for selling my uncle’s car because I needed the money to move into a new place](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/search?q=flair_name%3A"No A-holes here%22&restrict_sr=on)
  7. AITA I created a tech support Help Desk for my family and now they’re mad at me
  8. AITA for letting my ex-step daughter live with me? My ex wife is now trying to ruin me
  9. AITA for refusing to eat meat, and making my dad “waste food”?
  10. AITA for cooking my BF’s family Chinese food instead of “Chinese food”
  11. Update about my boyfriend.
  12. AITA for selling my wedding dress, so my sister can’t have it?
  13. Update: AITA for selling my wedding dress, so my sister cant have it?
  14. AITA for spending a lot of time in my bunker away from my family?
  15. Things are getting better. Update to Bunker post
  16. AITA for not giving my blessing to my daughter’s BF?
  17. My daughter’s roommate talked to me. Told me they will take care of her
  18. Mormons came into my door. I’m worried
  19. My daughter’s Mormon ex boyfriend made her choose between him and her family, she didn’t choose him
  20. AITA for cancelling the summer vacation with my sister in florida?
  21. AITA I’m not allowing my daughter to hang out with her older friends?
  22. AITA for inviting only one of my 2 moms to meet my girlfriend’s parents?
  23. AITA for telling my sister that she named her daughter after a prostitute?
  24. AITA for not wanting my autistic daughter at my home anymore?
  25. AITA for leaving my friend’s dog at a dog shelter after she abandoned him at my home?
  26. AITA I didn’t celebrate my daughter’s High School Graduation
  27. AITA for not celebrating my 3yo son’s birthday?
  28. AITA for getting myself to the hospital and making my dad get medical debt?
  29. AITA for telling my daughter I already knew she is a lesbian?
  30. I’m planning to redo my daughter’s coming out. Am I doing it right?
  31. UPDATE: Redoing my daughter’s coming out
  32. A customer freaks out after seeing a pride flag in my bakery
  33. AITA for telling my sister that she is a bad example? And that I don’t want her husband around my future child?
  34. AITA for telling my girlfriend she is a bad mother for making her daughter pay rent?
  35. Update for my AITA post.
  36. Someone reposted my story. Here’s some new events that happened
  37. AITA for not adopting my niece and sending her to foster care?
  38. AITA I shouted at the bride’s son at her own wedding after he broke my camera.
  39. AITA for not complimenting my niece at her quinceañera party?
  40. AITA for not warning my brother about the meaning of his Tattoo?
  41. A crazy woman attacked my daughter at the movies
  42. AITA for refusing to let my husband buy our dream home because is next to a school?
  43. AITA for the way I reacted after my wife came out?
    • quirzle@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      25
      ·
      1 year ago

      That’s such a strange reaction, since fake stories like yours are the only reason that sub has any content worth reading.

    • kgbbot@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Me too …but that might be because when I called out an AITA story and got a 3 day ban I made u/aita_mods_are_all_incels they really really didn’t like that…turns out I might have hit too close to home accidentally.

  • iNeedScissors67@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    1 year ago

    My wife loves AITA even though she’s fully aware that most of them are fake. I’m sending this list to her to see if she recognizes any lol

  • CleverNameAndNumbers@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    1 year ago

    I mean, it kinda sounds like you got hooked on the dopamine rush of social media and that you enjoy creative writing. I’d say all you need to do is channel that into more productive storytelling and you’ll be well on your way to being a good writer. I’m certain there’s creative writing communities out there that include roleplaying as part of it too. Creepypastas are all about that, albeit with a horror twist.

    Maybe the throwaway nature made it safe to exercise your creative muscles so-to-speak ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

  • Blackspider1111@lemmy.one
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    1 year ago

    You have to be a certain kind of creative to write this kind of stuff. I have no idea how to do it but you should write sitcoms lol

  • LiesSlander@beehaw.org
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    1 year ago

    I’m honestly impressed. Like, yeah, it isn’t cool to mislead people and whatnot but you know that. I hope you can find a creative writing outlet on Lemmy because I’d love to read your stories. Also, just because your stories aren’t in a book format doesn’t make them less real, if writing books is your goal then please seek it, but there are other formats that are no less “real”.

    Web serials, for example, tend to be first draft work so people are about as chill about grammar as they are on reddit. Or you could take a bunch of stories you made on the internet (like you have here) and make them into a collection someday if you really want to have a book. Point is, you are actually writing, and its good writing at that. Please keep doing it, and I hope you find a place where you feel good about what you’re making, whatever that looks like to you.

    • Didros@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 year ago

      They could write a 300 page book of these short stories and it would sell like hit cakes if brought to a publisher with a brain. This stuff is popular on reddit because it is popular content. Content creators just have not been making money on their work.

  • willya@lemmyf.uk
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    1 year ago

    Almost every time I seen a popular post from those communities hit my feed it read as fake to me.

    • vis4valentine@lemmy.mlOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      1 year ago

      Lol. In your opinion what fives away a story as fake the most? BTW did I ever reply to some of your comments calling out my story as fake?

      • lurkandtwerk@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        1 year ago

        You can usually tell it’s fake when the characters feel engineered to generate maximum outrage or sympathy.

        It’s possible you replied, but I only ever saw these posts when they would get enough traction to appear in r/all—so usually my comments came pretty late and never got more than a handful of votes. The few times OP did reply it was nonspecific stuff like “Fine, don’t believe me.”

        I’d check but all my reddit comments are gone now.

  • vis4valentine@lemmy.mlOP
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    1 year ago

    Am I the Angel Removed my post. I need advice, where on Reddit can I post it so it can have some visibility? The idea is for people to see my list.

  • Setarkus.LW@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    A man in a dimly lit room sits on the corner of a desk, speaking to the camera in a slow manner
    “Do you think this story is true, or do you think that our writers just made it all up? Let’s take a look at our next story first.”

    Kinda reminds me of this mystery show I can’t recall the name of :))
    I’d love to see a book or even just a “small” web series though. You probably amassed quite some experience on how to write characters to make them feel close to reality.