cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/1271267
What do you guys think about this? (Wasn’t sure which community to post this in)
all attention to this mess is good imho. also remember chat gpt was trained on reddit data i until fall 2021 so should be able to pull on archived zeitgeist for a quick and dirty answer
Not just with subs going private, but with users purging their comments and posts along with their accounts. Just last night I was talking to a friend about something and wanted to pull up a post from a while back. Lo and behold, deleted and gone.
Please post LINKS to Lemmy, not screenshots of headlines. Ffs, even your “source” link goes to an image, not the article
Mods, can we please crack down on this dumb-ification of Lemmy? We’re better than tiktok.
I wonder if they could shift to showing cached versions of pages, so that data is still accessible externally, but you can’t interact or get to it from reddit.
Great, now Google gets fucked as well! Another win.
I don’t think you understand, we are the ones who are getting fucked. Search results are getting worse and harder for you to find what you need with all the ads, fake news, sponsored sites, ai generated articles, etc… Google doesn’t care if you find high quality results, they will still gett traffic and their money because people won’t just stop using it.
Google is already an awful search engine and was most useful only for reddit. Search Engine Optimization killed it.
For example, do you know why every recipe Google shows has a 35 page life story article before the recipe? Because it takes you longer to scroll through the page and find the recipe and see if that’s what you want. So Google says oh, this website is good and entertaining and full of so many words! This goes higher up! They don’t write the stories because the bloggers care. They write stories because it’s the only way to get their website seen on Google.
Meanwhile the website you actually want… The one with a simple recipe and no fluff? Well that’s not going to sell itself to the Search Engine Optimization. So it’s much further down on the list, several pages down.
The same shitification is happening with every website. Every website is a little bit worse than it has to be simply to optimize it’s position on the almighty Google.
When you look for the “top shoes for running” or “best phone of 2023”, those are just rushed articles with no research done by people with the sole purpose of pumping out millions of articles just to get some spots on Google.
Google was only good for linking to reddit because reddit could never get their search engine working no matter how many times they tried it.
because reddit could never get their search engine working no matter how many times they tried it
In their defense, writing a good search engine is very hard, even if you own all the data yourself.
There’s a good reason why the litte search bar on reddit, on every forum ever created and on every corporate website is basically useless.
It’s also why, among other minor technological challenges (like caching and indexing the entire fediverse), there is no search engine for Lemmy. Nor will there likely ever be one. Which is actually a pitty, because finding valuable information in a comment stashed on some minor instance will be nearly impossible - even for google.
-
Don’t use Google.
-
Learn how to search the internet, its not hard.
-
Adblock is your friend.
-
People will stop using it only when it becomes unbearable. Their own business tbh.
What search engines you suggest? Duckduckgo is useless for me, but so is google nowadays tbh.
I like startpage. It’s not perfect but works. If I still cant find anything I search google. 95% of the time it just works.
@Stijn @krevassi, Startpage is probably one of the best search engines, I used it among others as second of my list, but for first searches I use 2 AI search engines which show me direct answers to complex questions.
https://andisearch.com
https://www.perplexity.ai
and sometimes also
https://you.comAll of these protect privacy and made by small independent startups
Reddit is still one of the best place to find answers by real people because of the disappearance of traditional forums.
Nah, it was.
Most of the answers are still there, just behind a locked door. So it will is, for the few who have access.
I’ve replaced probably 70% of my searching with ChatGPT.
Thats one hell of a bad idea.
-
There good and sometimes better alternatives to Google, you can easily leave without it or use it only when necessary
It doesn’t solve the issue that the answer you’re looking for is on Reddit and isn’t accessible anymore…
I mean, good for us for screwing up Reddit, but the transition impacts more than just Reddit itself because subreddits are going private and people are deleting their posts, that’s a whole lot of knowledge just disappearing from the internet overnight and that’s never a good thing! I don’t know how many times I tried to find solutions or answers to tech related questions and the only place I could find an actual answer was on Reddit because it was actual people speaking to each other!
Yeah, for the short term. But the long term if lemmy can become the successor. It won’t be long until it get will get back to normal
It took ten years for Reddit to reach that point, that’s a whole lot of info that people probably won’t talk about again but that might concern some people, just not as many as when the subject was new.
Example, my soundbar has technical issues when plugged in a certain way and that can be solved through some settings on the TV, the only answer I found was on Reddit on a sub that is now locked down. That soundbar isn’t for sale anymore and hasn’t been for a couple of years, so now I’m have to troubleshoot the issue by myself if I ever unplug it and if I sell it to someone when I upgrade then they’re shit out of luck 🤷